Summary

• College Football 25 and Madden NFL 25 have unique features and game modes that set the two games apart.
• College Football focuses on immersion and Dynasty mode, while Madden offers Superstar and Ultimate Team modes.
• The choice between the games depends on personal preference, with Madden appealing to NFL fans and College Football 25 offering a fresh experience.

Madden NFL 25 have some major differences in their game modes, at the end of the day, the gameplay is largely similar. Therefore, buying both just isn’t the most pragmatic option for many players.

When it comes to deciding between College Football 25 and Madden NFL 25, there are a few things players will want to consider. First is the features that are unique to the two games. Knowing what sets them apart is an important way to decide which game is the better purchase for any individual. Players likely also have personal preferences based on the teams and type of football played in each game. This means there is no one right answer here; instead, players will choose based on their personal preference.

College Football Is A Fresh Take On An Old Franchise

College Football 25 Is The First In The Series In Over A Decade

College Football 25 will be EA Sports’ first college football game in over 10 years, and a lot has changed since the days of NCAA Football 14. Aside from dropping the NCAA brand and being able to pay players for their likeness, EA Sports has taken quite a few steps to update the old franchise. One way they did this was by stepping up players’ sense of immersion.

EA Sports has taken steps to make College Football 25 reflect the experience of going to a college football game. This means including landmarks, celebrations, and team rituals that are unique to different schools. While not every school is treated equally — for instance, there are only 50 mascots despite there being 135 teams — there is still an impressive level of detail put into capturing the feel of each school’s stadium that alumni and fans of a given college will be impressed with how their team is represented.

College Football 25 also introduces a brand-new Dynasty mode, which allows players to take on the role of a college football coach. Players will sign a contract with a team, be in charge of recruiting new talent, and progress their coaching skills with several skill trees. Players can do this online with friends and even create custom divisions for their Dynasty league. These new features are breathing fresh life into the tried-and-true formula of football games.

Players Know What They’re Getting With Madden NFL 25

Madden NFL 25 Continues The Annual Franchise

Unlike EA’s college games, the Madden series has been going strong for years. While there have obviously been updates over the years to the series, they have been more gradual since this is an annual franchise. So, while there won’t be a huge change between Madden NFL 24 and Madden NFL 25, some players may just want an updated version of the series they already know they enjoy. Madden NFL 25 promises updates to its hit stick and its controls while running the ball.

Madden NFL 25 also has Superstar mode, which allows players to create a custom player and experience the game as an individual as opposed to a team. Updates to this mode include new player skills and a Superstar quest system that can help with player progression. Madden also has Ultimate Team mode, which allows players to create super teams with current and past NFL stars.

Similar to College Football 25, the new Madden has also put an emphasis on immersion. This means trying to capture the unique look and feel of each stadium. Though EA has not released a deep dive yet like they have with College Football, Madden fans can likely expect a similar attention to detail.

The Major Differences Between Madden NFL 25 And College Football 25

The Difference Largely Comes Down To Game Modes And The Leagues Each Focuses On

The most glaring difference between Madden NFL 25 and College Football 25 is the fact that Madden focuses on professional football instead of college football. Players who are more interested in the NFL than college sports will likely gravitate toward Madden, and vice versa. This difference isn’t just true when it comes to the teams available in each game, but is also reflected in the game modes.

For instance, someone playing Dynasty mode in College Football 25 is going to have a different experience than someone playing Madden’s Franchise mode because college football teams have to deal with the continual turnover of their best players. College Football 25 is also built to reflect the large experience gap between freshmen and senior players by allowing only experienced players to access certain mechanics, like jukes. Typically, Madden allows all players to do any move, just at varying levels of efficacy, and Madden NFL 25 hasn’t yet announced any features that will change that.

College Football 25 does have novelty on its side. After all, there hasn’t been a college football game by EA Sports in a decade, whereas there was a new Madden last year. Players who already own Madden NFL 24 may want to check out College Football 25 for the fresh experience it offers. Players will also be able to get their hands on College Football 25 about a month earlier than Madden NFL 25.

The Choice Between Madden & College Football Comes Down To Preference

Both Games Are Similar Enough That The Choice Is Up To Small Differences

At the end of the day, College Football 25 and Madden NFL 25 are games for the same sport, by the same company, using the same engine. Both games also cost the same amount: $69.99 for the standard edition or $99.99 for the deluxe edition. Which game a player decides to go with will largely come down to which type of football they have more interest in and which game’s modes attract them more. Dynasty mode is likely College Football 25’s biggest selling point, whereas Madden’s Ultimate Team is a big draw for football fans.

For players who decide they want both, it may be good to note that the MVP Bundle that EA Sports is offering for the games might not automatically be the way to go. The bundle is of the deluxe editions for College Football 25 and Madden 25, which upcharge for some in-game currency and a few minor in-game items. While the bundle is a good deal for players already considering buying the deluxe edition of both games, players can save about $10 by just purchasing each game’s standard edition individually.